Top 16 Thrift Stores in NYC that you Won’t Find Anywhere Else

Thrifting is a lot like a treasure hunt. You never know what you’re going to find! If you live in the NYC area or will be visiting, shopping at thrift stores is a must because they have some of the hottest stores with the most unique finds.

Check out the top 16 thrift stores NYC has to offer below.

1. AuH20

AuH20 is a second-hand ‘boutique’ as they call themselves. They sell vintage, secondhand clothing and accessories at affordable prices. When you shop in-store, make sure to check out their permanent $5 and $10 racks where nothing is over $5 – $10. 

Address: 84 E 7th St

NY, NY 10003

Phone: 917-261-7474

Hours: Tuesday – Sunday 12 – 7

2. 10 Ft Single by Stella Dallas

10 Ft Single by Stella Dallas sells vintage clothing in all price ranges from clearance type pricing to designer prices. You’ll find vintage clothing for women and kids there in all styles and sizes. Don’t forget to check out the backroom for the designer items.

Address: 285 N 6th St

Brooklyn, NY 11211

Phone: 718-486-9487

Hours: Daily 12 – 7:15

3. Chelsea Flea

Chelsea Flea Market is a year-round flea market open only on the weekends. Each weekend is like a new adventure as new items are added and they add new vendors every spring for even more changes. You’ll find everything you could need and more including clothing, accessories, shoes, and items for the home at exceptional prices. 

Address: 29 W 25th St

Btw 5th & 6th Ave

Hours: Saturday and Sunday 8 – 5

4. Beacon’s Closet

If you’re looking for the best vintage items in NYC, locals say you’ll find them at Beacon’s Closet. You’ll find the most incredible options for clothing, shoes, and accessories for men and women. They also offer the option to sell vintage items you have at home but no longer want. They typically buy for specific seasons but will buy specific items year-round.

Address: 10 W 13th St

NY, NY 10011

Other locations

Phone: 917-261-4863

Hours: 11 – 8 Daily

5. Buffalo Exchange

If you dream of designer clothes but can’t afford the price tags, head over to Buffalo Exchange where you could get your hand on some of the top designer clothing and accessories at a fraction of the price. They buy and sell women’s clothing and often run amazing sales that you won’t want to miss. 

*To sell items to the Buffalo Exchange, you must make an appointment.

Address: 5 locations

Phone: 212-260-9340

Hours: Monday – Saturday 11 AM – 8 PM and Sunday 11 AM – 7 PM

6. L Train Vintage

L Train Vintage is a family-owned vintage shop that buys vintage items from all over the country. They’ve been in business since 1999 and have many locations. Each location has new products at least 3 times a week and there’s always something exciting to find there!

*Note, all sales are final.

Address: 204 1st Ave

NY, NY 10009

Hours: Sunday – Thursday 12 PM – 7 PM and Friday – Saturday 12 PM – 8 PM

7. Laced Up

Laced Up is a sneaker lover’s dream come true. What started as a small mom-and-pop shop has grown tremendously and they now offer the hottest brands at secondhand prices. Across their 6 stores, you’ll find 2,000+ products in all the hottest names and trends from shoes, to t-shirts and accessories

Address: 684 Broadway

New York, NY 10012

Hours: 12 PM – 7 PM daily

8. Cure Thrift Shop

Cure Thrift Shop is a non-profit store benefitting juvenile diabetes. The owner, Liz, comes from a long line of thrifters and has taken her skills along with her passion for antiques and created an incredible thrift shop with a mission. In business since 2008, the store has a wonderful mixture of clothing and home goods that you won’t find anywhere else.

Address: 27 Howard St

NY, NY 10003

Phone: 212-505-SHOP

Hours: Daily 12 PM – 9 PM

9. 2nd Street

At 2nd Street USA you can get your hands on quality secondhand clothing you can’t find anywhere else. They offer an online shop as well as several locations to shop in-store. 2nd Street buys quality and trendy clothing from you too, if you want to make a little money, they are always on the lookout for new items.

Address: 1282 3rd Ave

NY, NY 10013

Phone: 646-907-5355

Hours: Monday – Sunday 11 AM – 8 PM

10. Tired Thrift

Tired Thrift was founded by two New Yorkers who were tired of the same fashion being sold at every store. They were also concerned about the damage new clothing was doing to the environment, so Tired Thrift was born. They focus on trends that come back, showcasing trends from the 90s and 2000s because we all know those trends are back and here to stay!

Address: 10 Bedford Ave

Brooklyn, NY 11222

Phone: 929-276-3002

Hours: Monday – Saturday 11 AM to 7 PM and Sunday 11 AM to 6 PM

11. CrossRoads Trading

CrossRoads Trading buys and sells vintage clothes every day. In business since 1991, they were one of the first companies to offer thrift shopping for today’s hottest fashions. They boast a large selection of clothing for men and women to help each one of us do our part to save the environment.

Address: 24 W 26th St

NY, NY 10010

Phone: 646-398-7917

Hours: Monday – Sunday 11 AM – 7 PM 

12. The Attic

At The Attic, you’ll find trendy men’s and women’s clothes second-hand at amazing prices. Their mission is to put less clothing in landfills, helping to save our environment. They provide a modern shopping experience that will leave your wallet happy while satisfying your inner fashionista.

Address: 231 Grand Street

Brooklyn, NY 11211

Phone: 929-276-3533

Hours: Monday – Saturday 11 AM – 8 PM and Sunday 11 AM – 6 PM

13. Rogue

Rogue sells some of the trendiest secondhand clothing for women and teens in New York. Get your favorites in-store or shop online and enjoy their incredible packaging all while doing your part to save the environment.

Address: 53A Stanton St

NY, NY 10002

Phone: 908-285-1292

14. Grand Street Local

Grand Street Local is a family-owned thrift shop in NYC. They travel the country to find the best vintage clothing to sell in their store. You’ll find band tees, college gear, cartoons, and other specialty clothing brands at Grand Street Local. They are your one-stop-shop for all things fun and secondhand!

Address: 154 Grand St

Brooklyn, NY 11249

Phone: 917-909-1882

15. Le Point Value Thrift

Find quality secondhand clothing for the entire family at Le Point Value Thrift. They sell all brands and sizes to help you save money on clothing and accessories for the entire family from kids to parents!

Address: 1321 Rogers Ave

Brooklyn, NY 11210

Phone: 347-533-6821

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10 AM – 5:30 PM

16. Awoke Vintage

Awoke Vintage isn’t your usual thrift shop. They partner with media outlets, producers, and more to come up with incredible outfits for events and projects. They have a wide reach of suppliers and have the most incredible selection of thrift clothing and if you can’t make it into their store, you can even shop via Instagram.

Address: 132 N 5th St

Brooklyn, NY 11249

Phone: 718-387-3130

Hours: 10 AM – 9 PM daily

NYC Thrift Stores FAQs

Is NYC good for thrifting?

New York City has the largest selection of thrift stores in the country. You’ll find thrift stores on every corner, but finding the right ones takes a little time. It can be a lot like a treasure hunt as you go from store to store looking for the perfect vintage piece that will complete your wardrobe.

Is shopping at thrift stores worth it?

You might think shopping at thrift stores is too much work, but it can be a lot of fun! Not only will you save a ton of money, but you’ll also find pieces you wouldn’t otherwise find anywhere else. Some of the stores we’ve listed travel the country to find the hottest items and some even specialize in certain decades to help you take advantage of the trends that are coming back to stay.

What does it mean to go thrifting?

When someone says they are going thrifting, they are usually shopping at thrift stores, but they may also be shopping at garage sales or flea markets. The bottom line is they are buying secondhand clothing that is vintage, and trendy and helping to save the environment.

How do thrift stores work?

Thrift store owners find second-hand clothing they think others will love. They sometimes buy from customers who want to sell or they travel the world curating pieces themselves. Either way, they sell the items in their store for a fraction of the cost of the original retail price.

Final Thoughts – Thrift Stores in New York City

If you’ve never been thrifting, give it a try. If you’re in NYC, there’s no better place to do it. You’ll find the best clothing at the most amazing prices and you might even score clothing from around the country!

Kim Pinnelli is a personal finance freelance writer and contributor. She lives in the Chicago suburbs, writing from home for the last 13 years. Kim enjoys helping people understand personal finances and writes on topics about saving money, investing, planning for retirement, and ways to increase income. In her free time, Kim enjoys hanging out with her 3 children, reading, crocheting, and spending time outdoors.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Register New Account
Reset Password